Case Study: A Long Road to Removing a Problem Tenant

The owner of a multi-unit building had struggled for years with a disruptive tenant who repeatedly violated community rules and harassed other residents. Although many tenants complained, none were willing to testify in court, making it nearly impossible to pursue a nuisance eviction.

The situation finally changed when the tenant stopped paying rent. McLaughlin Sanchez served a three-day notice to pay rent or quit and filed an unlawful detainer case when the tenant failed to pay.

The case was far from simple. The tenant raised multiple defenses and the San Francisco court required several settlement conferences before allowing the matter to proceed to trial. After two days in court, the judge ruled in the landlord’s favor - awarding possession of the property and a judgment for the unpaid rent.

As the client later shared:

"Miracles happened with your guidance, judgment, and tenacity. It was a lengthy process, but it paid off.

Although we had to evict someone for reasons beyond our control, it was a relief to learn at trial that your firm's reputation is highly respected by other lawyers, including tenant rights groups, and even judges, for being ethical, reasonable, and respectful to everyone, regardless of the circumstances. The tenants in our building rejoiced knowing that their safety would no longer be jeopardized and that they would not be accosted or harassed by that tenant anymore.

We are truly grateful for all that was done for us to resolve this matter and reach such a necessary outcome. It has truly been life-changing for the rest of the tenants in our building. As housing providers, we felt a very heavy responsibility to provide the best environment for our tenants, and with your help, we succeeded."

When the Sheriff ultimately removed the tenant, it brought long-awaited relief to both the owner and the other residents in the building.